Without fans, home advantage shrank — and came back with them.
The pooled xG home edge went from +30% with fans before 2020 to +13% behind closed doors, then back to +26% when crowds returned.
Pooled team xG home edge, by period
Home ÷ away, team level, all five leagues.
The xG home edge fell from +30% (with fans, before 2020) to +13% without crowds and recovered to +26% when they returned.
Study 01 · Final Summary §3 (team level)
Every league lost xG home advantage without fans; Ligue 1 lost its whole goals edge.